U.S. schools are saying goodbye to foreign languages
|
|---|
| | | Title of original article in _The Atlantic_ is misleading and incorrectly over-generalizing | Dec 20, 2014 |
Greetings to all.
The title of that cited original article appearing in an issue of _The Atlantic_ is misleading and incorrectly over-generalizing, as the writer used the situation in that one school in NYC as an example for extrapolating and then segueing the piece into an implicit characterization of apparently all "U.S. Schools...".
While the situation regarding programs for foreign language instruction in a number of public and private secondary schools here is Califor... See more Greetings to all.
The title of that cited original article appearing in an issue of _The Atlantic_ is misleading and incorrectly over-generalizing, as the writer used the situation in that one school in NYC as an example for extrapolating and then segueing the piece into an implicit characterization of apparently all "U.S. Schools...".
While the situation regarding programs for foreign language instruction in a number of public and private secondary schools here is California tend to range from bleak to (ahem) variable, generalizations are unfounded and unhelpful. What the students' parents, local school boards, and ultimately, employers want seems to determine what gets taught, how much and how well.
Surprised that < proz.com > considered that flawed and superficial article as worthy of posting as a serious item.
Regards,
Stephen H. Franke
Senior veteran Arabic linguist, dialectologist,
trainer, and educator
San Pedro (Los Angeles Waterfront Area), California ▲ Collapse
| | | | John Fossey 
Канада
Local time: 12:09
Член ProZ.com c 2008
французский => английский
+ ...
What about Spanish? Or is that not considered a "foreign" language in the US?
| | | |
"And by the way, Americans don’t tend to do foreign languages very well... But my son took three years of French and he could barely say, “How are you?” … "
Sad on so many levels. Sad that Moskovitz bases her judgement of whether a whole nation should learn foreign languages on her son's experience and competence (or lack of).
Coming from the UK, I think the US suffers from the same linguistic imperialism of expecting the rest of the world to understand Eng... See more "And by the way, Americans don’t tend to do foreign languages very well... But my son took three years of French and he could barely say, “How are you?” … "
Sad on so many levels. Sad that Moskovitz bases her judgement of whether a whole nation should learn foreign languages on her son's experience and competence (or lack of).
Coming from the UK, I think the US suffers from the same linguistic imperialism of expecting the rest of the world to understand English. But to me, the effects of learning a foreign language go deeper than mere linguistic prowess; it means the willingness and openness to learn about and accept other cultures. And I feel that the schools in question - and the US as a whole - should take a long hard look at what they are choosing to teach their children.
After all, it is not about how "good" the future generations will be at foreign languages that matters. Fear of inadequacy should not be a deciding factor. ▲ Collapse
| | | | Jonathan Norris
США
Local time: 09:09
Член ProZ.com c 2009
испанский => английский
+ ...
| Re: sad and misleading | Dec 22, 2014 |
I just want to support the other posts, first that this article in no way reflects the state of education in the U.S. as a whole. Simply interviewing the "CEO" of some private school in Brooklyn is not representative of anything but that specific private school. And when you name your school "Success Academy," you can't expect much. That's right, I eat my dinner at "Healthy Hamburger Restaurant," attend "Success Academy" for school, my dog's name is "Good Doggy," and my parents' names are St... See more I just want to support the other posts, first that this article in no way reflects the state of education in the U.S. as a whole. Simply interviewing the "CEO" of some private school in Brooklyn is not representative of anything but that specific private school. And when you name your school "Success Academy," you can't expect much. That's right, I eat my dinner at "Healthy Hamburger Restaurant," attend "Success Academy" for school, my dog's name is "Good Doggy," and my parents' names are Strong and Caring. Good Grief.
Polling elementary and middle schools, where foreign language is hardly ever taught to begin with, basically skips over the largest contingent of learners in the U.S.: public high school students. Any conclusion based on that data is useless. It's like saying that football is on the decline based on a representative sample of women ages 65-70. Or vegetarianism is trending down among American carnivores. It's a no-brainer.
Besides, this woman is not a good ambassador for her organization. "We suck at it, so let's just quit." Soooo motivational. Did she then go on to say, "Foreign languages are stupid anyways. Everyone else speaks English already, so it is a waste of time to expect our children to learn them." No, in fact, it was the author of the article who said it, and even saw fit to end on that note.
[Edited at 2014-12-22 23:44 GMT] ▲ Collapse
| | |
|
|
|
Roy Williams
Австрия
Local time: 18:09
немецкий => английский
| Re: sad and misleading | Dec 23, 2014 |
Jonathan Norris wrote:
I just want to support the other posts, first that this article in no way reflects the state of education in the U.S. as a whole. Simply interviewing the "CEO" of some private school in Brooklyn is not representative of anything but that specific private school. And when you name your school "Success Academy," you can't expect much. That's right, I eat my dinner at "Healthy Hamburger Restaurant," attend "Success Academy" for school, my dog's name is "Good Doggy," and my parents' names are Strong and Caring. Good Grief.
Polling elementary and middle schools, where foreign language is hardly ever taught to begin with, basically skips over the largest contingent of learners in the U.S.: public high school students. Any conclusion based on that data is useless. It's like saying that football is on the decline based on a representative sample of women ages 65-70. Or vegetarianism is trending down among American carnivores. It's a no-brainer.
Thanks for the rollicking laugh!
| | | | Tom in London
Великобритания
Local time: 17:09
Член ProZ.com c 2008
итальянский => английский
| Language and culture | Dec 23, 2014 |
By learning a language, you're learning a whole culture. A door opens. You walk through it. From the other side, you look back at your own culture, seeing it objectively for the first time. There's nothing as good as this!
"Your own culture" is now an interaction between two cultures. You're rich!
Anybody who hasn't done this will not have the faintest idea of what I'm talking about.
[Edited at 2014-12-23 13:31 GMT]
| | | | Jonathan Norris
США
Local time: 09:09
Член ProZ.com c 2009
испанский => английский
+ ...
Roy Williams wrote:
Jonathan Norris wrote:
I just want to support the other posts, first that this article in no way reflects the state of education in the U.S. as a whole. Simply interviewing the "CEO" of some private school in Brooklyn is not representative of anything but that specific private school. And when you name your school "Success Academy," you can't expect much. That's right, I eat my dinner at "Healthy Hamburger Restaurant," attend "Success Academy" for school, my dog's name is "Good Doggy," and my parents' names are Strong and Caring. Good Grief.
Polling elementary and middle schools, where foreign language is hardly ever taught to begin with, basically skips over the largest contingent of learners in the U.S.: public high school students. Any conclusion based on that data is useless. It's like saying that football is on the decline based on a representative sample of women ages 65-70. Or vegetarianism is trending down among American carnivores. It's a no-brainer.
Thanks for the rollicking laugh!
Glad you like it.
| | | | Paul Lambert
Швеция
Local time: 18:09
Член ProZ.com c 2006
шведский => английский
+ ...
| Typical overly drastic headline | Dec 24, 2014 |
This is hardly the first time that a drastic headline grabs our attention only then to lead us into reading an article where the details give an entirely different impression.
| | |
|
|
|
DS Trans
США
Local time: 12:09
французский => английский
+ ...
| When did we say hello? | Dec 24, 2014 |
A decrease of 17% in middle schools offering a foreign language over 11 years seems significant to me. Harlem Success Academy is a large network of charter schools in NYC--highly regarded too.
Unfortunately I don't think I've ever met anyone who has come out of the public education system here with the ability to converse in a foreign language, except those who went to an immersion school. (I'm referring to native English speakers obviously.) Typically, high school graduates have ... See more A decrease of 17% in middle schools offering a foreign language over 11 years seems significant to me. Harlem Success Academy is a large network of charter schools in NYC--highly regarded too.
Unfortunately I don't think I've ever met anyone who has come out of the public education system here with the ability to converse in a foreign language, except those who went to an immersion school. (I'm referring to native English speakers obviously.) Typically, high school graduates have had six years of foreign-language studies by the time they graduate. It's pitiful.
My HS Spanish teacher didn't speak it, and I thought that would have changed by now, but I learned that our local Spanish MS teacher hardly speaks it as well! It says something about the university system, but that's another discussion. What's really ridiculous is that native Spanish speakers will sit in a classroom for 2 years with a teacher who doesn't speak the language (because no other foreign language is offered). I'm so frustrated writing about it that I almost agree with her decision. I don't see any long-term benefits to "learning" a foreign language under these conditions.
Really we should be starting foreign languages earlier at the very least, and revise the teaching methods to emulate countries with successful instruction. But the US is very bottom-line oriented, and even though the benefits on the brain are well documented, foreign languages, monetarily speaking, are very undervalued. I recently saw a hotel's employment ad asking for multilingual "room attendants" (cleaning staff).
And then you get some right wingers who are upset that so many people speak Spanish here already. I doubt they want to create more or encourage people to converse with each other in a language other than English.
End of rant. ▲ Collapse
| | | | Jennifer Lambert (X)
Китай
Local time: 01:09
немецкий => английский
+ ...
| RE:When did we say hello? | Dec 29, 2014 |
>>And then you get some right wingers who are upset that so many people speak Spanish here already
Can we keep this professional, please? There are "right wingers" who are multi-lingual and well-traveled.
| | | | Jennifer Lambert (X)
Китай
Local time: 01:09
немецкий => английский
+ ...
| RE:When did we say hello? | Dec 29, 2014 |
>>And then you get some right wingers who are upset that so many people speak Spanish here already
Can we keep this professional, please? There are "right wingers" who are multi-lingual and well-traveled.
| | | | | I second the motion. | Dec 30, 2014 |
Ziema26 wrote:
>>And then you get some right wingers who are upset that so many people speak Spanish here already
Can we keep this professional, please? There are "right wingers" who are multi-lingual and well-traveled.
I second the motion. DS Trans's remark is uncalled for.
| | |
|
|
|
DS Trans
США
Local time: 12:09
французский => английский
+ ...
| Sorry to offend | Dec 31, 2014 |
It wasn't my purpose to offend. It would be great if we could embrace multilingualism in the US, but we don't and it shows in our educational priorities. Unfortunately it's not uncommon to hear people complain about those speaking other languages, particularly Spanish, and there's a political component to it.
[Edited at 2014-12-31 19:42 GMT]
| | | | Daryo
Великобритания
Local time: 17:09
сербский => английский
+ ...
| Language and culture | Jan 4, 2015 |
[quote]Tom in London wrote:
...
Anybody who hasn't done this will not have the faintest idea of what I'm talking about.
quite true - and unfortunately applies to the vast majority in almost every country ...
| | | |
My daughter (here in the US) has had Spanish classes every year since she was in the 3rd grade (10th grade now).
[Edited at 2015-01-08 13:18 GMT]
| | | | To report site rules violations or get help, contact a site moderator: You can also contact site staff by submitting a support request » U.S. schools are saying goodbye to foreign languages | TM-Town | Manage your TMs and Terms ... and boost your translation business
Are you ready for something fresh in the industry? TM-Town is a unique new site for you -- the freelance translator -- to store, manage and share translation memories (TMs) and glossaries...and potentially meet new clients on the basis of your prior work.
More info » |
| | Anycount & Translation Office 3000 | Translation Office 3000
Translation Office 3000 is an advanced accounting tool for freelance translators and small agencies. TO3000 easily and seamlessly integrates with the business life of professional freelance translators.
More info » |
|
| | | | X Sign in to your ProZ.com account... | | | | | |
Login to reply/comment 
Translation news
